How to Figure Out What Wine You Actually Like (Without the Snobbery)

I spent years ordering wine I didn't particularly like, on purpose. I came out of college wanting nothing but sweet wine, and then spent my twenties at fancy work dinners (at restaurants I could not have afforded on my own) ordering heavy reds because that seemed like what a person with sophisticated sensibilities would do. If you had asked me what I actually liked, I couldn't have told you. I could only tell you the season: heavy reds when it got cold, rosé in June.

Here is what I wish someone had told me back then: you already know what you like. You have a fully formed palate and you use it every day, on coffee, on snacks, on cocktails. Nobody ever hands you the translation key. So here it is.

Your coffee order is a wine prediction

• Black coffee, no apologies. You tolerate bitterness, maybe even enjoy it. You'll probably love big reds like Cabernet Sauvignon, Malbec, and Syrah. That grippy, drying feeling in bold reds is tannin, and black coffee drinkers barely notice it.
• Cream and sugar. You like smooth and rounded. Start with Pinot Noir or Merlot on the red side, Chardonnay on the white.
• Sweet and iced. You like sweet, and that is a real palate, not a starter palate. Riesling and Moscato are your lane, and German Riesling is some of the most respected wine on the planet, whatever the next table thinks.
• Tea person. You favor delicate and aromatic. Try a dry rosé or a light sparkling wine.

Your snacks are the second clue

• Dark chocolate and berries: bold reds again. Same flavor family, dark fruit with a little bitterness and richness.
• Brie and warm bread: creamy whites like Chardonnay, or a silky Pinot Noir.
• Chips, salsa, salty things: crisp whites like Sauvignon Blanc, and anything bubbly. Salt loves acidity, which is why fries and Champagne is a famous pairing among people who know.
• Peach cobbler, honey, the dessert order: Riesling, Moscato, Chenin Blanc.

The three-bottle experiment

When I finally got serious about wine (a story that involves my parents planning a wine bar, my own competitive streak, and a failed first exam I don't love talking about), the thing that actually taught me wasn't the workbook. It was tasting with a little intention. You don't need a 12-bottle case. You need three bottles and about $40:

1. One crowd-pleaser red: a Spanish Garnacha or a Pinot Noir.
2. One zippy white: a New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc. It's the loudest version of the style, which makes it perfect for figuring out where you stand.
3. One wildcard: a dry rosé, a Riesling, or a Cava, whichever sounded best in the sections above.

Open them over the course of a week. Don't take notes, and please don't swirl for an audience. Just notice one thing per glass: did you want a second sip? Most of wine expertise is that question, asked honestly.

Words you can ignore (and the two that matter)

You do not need "barnyard," "graphite," or "wet slate." You need two words:

• Dry just means not sweet. Most wine is dry.
• Body is how heavy the wine feels in your mouth. Think skim milk (light), whole milk (medium), cream (full). Big reds are cream. Riesling is skim.

With those two words you can talk to any wine shop employee in America. "I want a dry, full-bodied red under $20" is a complete, respected sentence. So is "I like sweet wine, what's a good one?" I promise the second one gets a warmer reception than you'd expect.

Three myths I believed for years

• Expensive means better. Above about $15, price mostly tracks scarcity and marketing. The $12 to $25 range is where quality per dollar peaks, and it's where wine professionals shop for their own weeknights.
• Red wine is for experts, sweet wine is for beginners. Palates aren't ranked, they're just different, like music taste. I ordered serious reds for years to seem mature. Nobody was fooled, and I missed out on a lot of Riesling.
• "I don't like Chardonnay." You probably met one heavily oaked Chardonnay at a party once and held a grudge. Unoaked Chardonnay is a different wine entirely: clean, pear-y, easy to love.

Or take the shortcut

We turned this whole article into a 60-second quiz: your coffee order, your snack plate, your budget, the occasion. It hands you a named taste profile and specific bottles to hunt down.

Provenance Club may earn a commission from wine partners linked on this site. It never changes your price. For adults 21+.